Mubarak Dahir
'Before the War' is a collection of articles published on Temenos before the War in Iraq began. These pieces are being re-published to remember where we have been and reflect on where we're going.
A helicopter is swarming overhead, making a circle
in the air roughly the area of Vienna's 1st District, the
section of this city that holds its most famous palaces,
monuments and museums.
As snowflakes float from the sky, I walk through one of the
many arched walkways of Hofburg, the extravagant Imperial
Palace of the Habpsburg's, and head toward the Pestsaule, or
the Plague Monument, the center of the day's activity.
As I make my way through Vienna's sometimes maze-like
alleys, I notice gaggles of Austrian police decked out in riot
gear. They stand in small groups, smoking cigarettes, and,
like everyone elsewhere in Austria and around the world- they
are anxiously waiting.
In particular, the police are waiting for the day's
anti-war protest to begin. But the real waiting game and the
deeper anxiety for all of us comes from wondering just when
American bombs might start exploding in Iraq.
Should LGBT
Organizations take a position on the War in
Iraq?
The demonstration today is against that seemingly
inevitable action. It's an international day of protest, with
similar rallies being held in capitals across the world. Away
from home, I want to somehow be a part of the voices calling
for restraint against George Bush's single-minded vision for
military action in Iraq, so I follow the crowds of
demonstrators with hand-made cardboard signs to Pestsaule
Square, the epicenter of the peace march.
Located on one of Vienna's most famous shopping streets,
and just in the shadow of the majestic St. Stephan's
Cathedral, the square is marked by a towering stone monument
in its center. The Baroque carving of cherubs and saints was
put in place in 1692 to celebrate the end of the black plague
that had decimated Europe.
It's a fitting site for today's protest, as there seems to
be a deadly bug being spread by the American government: The
idea that war in Iraq is the world's only option.
Much of the world, including many Americans, don't believe
it. In Vienna, I huddled with 15,000 people to raise our
voices against George Bush's belligerent march towards war. In
dozens of other cities, a combined millions of people did the
same.
There are some in the gay and Lesbian community who will
object to this column, who will say that gay writers and
thinkers shouldn't be espousing their opinions on the war in a
community newspaper. These critics will argue that the war
isn't a "Gay issue."
I couldn't disagree more. On the contrary, I believe that
particularly as Gay and Lesbian people, we are specially
situated to act as skeptics and critics to questionable
government policies and outright misinformation- especially
when government policies could result in an unknown death
toll. With all that we have collectively learned from our own
history as gay and Lesbian people, it would be a shame if we
limited our critical thinking abilities and our questioning
voices to a narrow range of topics.
In fact, rather than limiting our thoughts and discussions
to a narrowly defined set of "Gay issues," I believe we have a
responsibility to expand our scope. We can't harp about our
own human rights and ignore everyone else's- particularly when
we are citizens of the most powerful country in the world. A
country that is not shy about using its military might to
wrestle what it wants in other parts of the world. Now more
than ever is when we need to exercise our skepticism
publicly.
Despite the idealistic notion that we as Americans value
individuality, the hard truth is that in our society - as in
most societies - it's often very difficult and takes a lot of
courage to voice unpopular opinions. It's particularly hard
when it comes to questioning authority, especially if that
authority is as powerful and forceful as the president of the
United States. Even worse, many people will call us
"un-American" or "unpatriotic" for doing so.
During times of crises, it's understandable that most
people have an automatic reflex to support their own
government. For us as gay and Lesbian people, there may be
another powerful force pulling us to support the
administration's move toward war: We all know what it's like
to be outsiders. For many of us, being Gay or Lesbian has
meant that we have been the ultimate outsiders from American
society for much of our own lives. Now, especially in the
light of so much European objection to America's handling of
Iraq, there will be a natural tendency for many of us to want
to "prove" our patriotism, to want to show other Americans we
are "just as American" as they are, to band together as
full-fledged team players, so that we can finally "belong" in
a way that we might not always get to do.
But as Gay and Lesbian people, I believe we have a special
place in public discourse, and I think part of that includes a
special responsibility to be willing to ask tough, unpopular
questions, to exhibit unapologetic skepticism, and to take up
a broad band of human rights issues that may not narrowly
relate to the single topic of how we have sex.
And even as I stand in a foreign country to make my voice
heard through this protest, I can't imagine what could be more
American.
Mubarak Dahir receives e-mail here.
To hear from more LGBT individuals who oppose the war with
Iraq, visit OUT Against
the War!