Tod Companion
Gay and Lesbian people have many equality issues,
many are shared, but some are gender specific. In the case of
Lesbians, there is a great health care disparity between them
and heterosexual women. At first this was dismissed, owing
largely to biases within the mostly male medical community.
But research shows that the problem runs deeper, leading to
some avoidable health issues for the lesbian community.
The Big C
Studies by the National Cancer Institute (NCI) have
demonstrated that while being a lesbian does not appear to
increase the chance of contracting any particular form of
cancer, there are lifestyle circumstances affecting occurance,
diagnosis and treatment.
| Join the Temenos Lesbian Health Yahoo Group: click here |
The risk of cancer for all women is the same, according to
the NCI. One in every three women will get cancer in her
lifetime. Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer deaths
among women. 1 in every 9 women will get breast cancer.
According to the Mautner project, a non-profit organization
for support and eduction of lesbians with cancer,
socioeconomic conditions and homophobia contribute to delayed
diagnosis, and therefore increased risk and mortality from
cancer in the lesbian community.
Lesbians, according to the project, are less likely to seek
health care. Dr. Katherine O'Hanlan, author of a 1995 Stanford
University report, feels that "Lesbians have been alienated
from the medical practice, either by accidental offense by a
well meaning doctor, or by prejudice." The biggest factor, Dr.
O'Hanlan feels, is internalized homophobia, which sabotages
self-esteem, and results in poor health habits and low
compliance with health care plans. Because they tend to visit
the doctor less often, the report found that lesbians are at
increased risk for breast, ovarian and endometrial carcinoma,
as well as heart disease.
This discomfort of coming out to health care providers is
confirmed by studies as recent as 1995. 84% of lesbians
surveyed in one study reported they were uncomfortable seeking
Healthcare. Non-empathetic (insensitive) responses for health
care providers were given as the main reason for this
discomfort.
With fewer visits to the doctor, normal gynecological
services such as birth control and pre-natal care are
performed less often. Therefore, cancers are less likely to be
detected at earlier, more tangible stages. Early detection is
critical for effective cancer treatment.
Even with regular OB-GYN care, lesbians are at higher risk
for breast, cervical and ovarian cancers because they are less
likely to have children by age 30, if at all. Pregnancy later
in life seems to increase the risk for these forms of cancer.
Economics also influences the average lesbians risk for
cancer. Lesbians are more directly influenced by women's lower
earning power. Most do not have the benefit of spousal health
insurance coverage. Again, due to economics, lesbians may be
seen less often by medical professionals, so routine screening
is not performed. Many forms of cancer are treatable, but only
if the diagnosis is made early.
Oncologists recommend that ALL women do the following to
reduce the risk of cancer:
- Stop Smoking - this will improve your health generally,
and reduce your risk for lung cancer, the leading cause of
cancer deaths among women.
- Have an annual PAP smear, breast and pelvic exam - These
tests can quickly pinpoint problems early: Early detection
means better treatment and higher probability of survival.
- Have an annual mammogram after age 35.
- Perform a monthly breast self-exam. If you are not sure
how, call a women's health care office, or visit
www.mautnerproject.org.
- Avoid excessive exposure to the sun.
- Establish a healthy and balanced diet. Low fat, high
fiber diets decrease the risk of several forms of cancer.
Establish an open relationship with your health care
provider. Visit them on a regular basis. The check-up you skip
may be the one that catches the lump. One of the studies
mentioned above found that 12% of lesbians found that coming
out to their physician had a negative effect on their health
care. Change doctors if this seems to be the case.
More than Cancer
While lesbians in general are at lower risk for most STDs,
studies indicate that nearly 70% of lesbians have had sex with
a man at least once, which means they are still at risk for
STDs common to heterosexual women. Pap smears and other STD
tests are therefore recommended for all women, regardless of
sexual orientation.
This is another topic, highlighted by the Stanford study,
where uninformed doctors neglected their lesbian patients.
Most were not aware of the need for pap smears and STD testing
for lesbians.
In Montreal, Canada, a study of the lesbian community found
that nearly 90% had been diagnosed with chlamydia, and 50%
with bacterial vaginosis. Some diseases, like chlamydia and
gonorrhoea, remain asymptomatic until diagnosed by a
gynecological exam: complete gynecological exams and pap
smears are a must for all sexually active women.
HIV
What about HIV in the lesbian community? Since the
mid-1980's, it has been documented that HIV can be passed
between women. Besides sex, HIV can be transmitted by: donor
insemination, needles, piercing and tattooing.
Body and Soul
A 1994 study by the American Psychological Association
(APA) indicates that lesbians are active in seeking mental and
spiritual health, and that those in the closet are more likely
to seek professional counseling that those who are "out."
Surveying the professionals who work in the mental health
field, the APA found that providers tend to overestimate the
kinds of psychological problems faced by lesbians, but are
well informed on the effects of social discrimination. They
rated physical and sexual abuse and suicide as severe
problems, well outside the real ranges, according to the study
authors.
Nearly three quarters of lesbians surveyed had, at one
time, sought mental health care. More than a third, at the
time of the study, were currently seeing a counselor or
therapist. The subjects lacked confidence in mental health
care professionals, but still found the services beneficial.
Overall, it appears that the disparity between heterosexual
and lesbian health care can be overcome. Honesty with one's
physician, insistence on regular, detailed OB-GYN exams and
tests can overcome the tendency for the medical profession to
ignore circumstances specific to Lesbians.
Here are some links related to this column:
Mautner Project for
Lesbians with Cancer
Here are some other jumping off points:
The Lesbian Health Web Ring Home Page
Here are some more general links:
Some
Of Beverly's Favorite Lesbian Links
Office of
Women's Health Home Page
More resources on LGBTI Health can be found on the Temenos Health Page