T.M. Witten, A. Evan Eyler and Cathy Weigel
Reprinted from 'Outword', the newsletter of the
Lesbian and Gay Aging Issues Network of the American Society on
Aging
Although they are often invisible to professionals in the field
of aging - and indeed to society in general - transgender (TG) and
transsexual (TS) individuals clearly form a more than negligible
percentage of the U.S. population. These elders not only require the
same care as all older adults, they also need care - and face
obstacles - specifically related to their gender status.
Female-to-male (FTM) transsexuals and transgenders usually
self-identify during their teens, 20s or 30s, often following a long
period of self-identifying as a lesbian. By contrast, male-tofemale
(MTF) transsexuals and transgenders more often attempt to suppress
their gender identity for years or decades, first expressing their
variance socially or seeking sex-reassignment services during
midlife or older age.
Quality-of-life issues for all TG/TS individuals at midlife and
in old age may be affected by a range of medical and social
considerations. These issues in some cases are similar to those
encountered by all older adults, and in many other cases are
distinctive to those who are making or have made a gender
transition.l The following overview briefly outlines a number of
such issues that should be of concern to service providers in aging.
Medical Issues
People who undertake gender transition through hormone therapy or
full sex-reassignment surgery during midlife or the older years are
more likely than their younger peers to face obstacles related to
physical health. Aging-related conditions, especially cardiac or
pulmonary dysfunction, may make an individual ineligible for
surgical procedures - including breast or genital reconstruction -
that medical professionals deem elective.
In addition, genetic males seeking transition to the female
gender may be poor candidates for estrogen therapy if their medical
history incloudes various conditions more common in older adults:
moderate or severe hypertension, pathologic hypercoagulable states
or thromboembolic disease, or uncontrolled diabetes mellitus. Those
receiving medical treatment involving unusually comlicated
pharmacological regimens also may be ruled out. Conversely, MTF
individuals with prostate disease may experience medically
beneficial side effects from gender related estrogen treatment.
In FTMs, androgen supplementation does not cause problems with
hypercoagulability, but it does increase the risk of coronary artery
disease and may exacerbate dyslipidemias such as depressed HDL
cholesterol. Androgen supplementation also is a risk factor for the
development of polycthemia (increased red blood cell count), a
potentially life-threatening condition. At the same time, it may
have medically therapeutic value for FTMs with preexisting anemia or
loss of bone mineralization.
Healthcare and Personal Assistance
Because of prejudice and rigid gender expectations on the part of
service providers, TG/TS elders can encounter problems in gaining
access to healthcare and personal assistance services. Older
postoperative transsexuals who can "pass," even when nude, have the
least difficulty. (Due to the current differences in the outcomes of
reconstructive surgery for female vs. male genitals, this advantage
is overwhelmingly experienced by MTF individuals.)
For TG/TS older adults who face varying degress of difficulty in
passing, the apparent mismatch between their genital anatomy and
their social gender can result in difficulty in obtaining medical
care, practical nursing assistance and even mortuary services. In
addition, many medical personnel consider transgenderism,
transsexualism, and cross-dressing tobe evidence of psychiatric
pathology. As a result of such mistaken notions, healthcare
professionals may make inappropriate psychiatric referrals.
Middle-aged and older cross-dressers often experience difficulty
in obtaining healthcare services due to privacy concerns. For
example, most MTF cross-dressers remove leg and body hair in order
to appear as normal women while dressed as women. When they need
medical assistance, they face the dilemma of either disclosing their
cross-dressing behavior or attempting to postpone services until the
body hair has regrown. Such delays in obtaining medical care can
have serious health consequences.
HIV and AIDS
HIV and AIDS have been of increasing concern in the TG/TS and
cross-dressing populations. Those who have suppressed their gender
identity during adolescence or early adulthood at times enjoy a
"second adolescence" when they begin to socialize in their true
psychological gender, adopting behaviors that may include risky
dating and sexual acting out. Such behaviors may increase the risk
of HIV infection, a situation that challenges service providers to
create effective and culturally appropriate risk-reduction
strategies for this population.
HIV infection in later life also presents special financial
comlications for TG/TS older adults: They may face the burden of
paying for contragender hormone therapy or transsexual surgical
services as well as treatments for chronic conditions that accompany
aging, while at the same time taking on the expense of HIV
antivirals. in addition to the cost, elders in this situation may
find it difficult to comply with required drug regimens; the "pill
burden" may be very difficult to maintainon a daily basis.
Oral Health
Oral health is a particular concern for older MTFs who are
receiving a hormone regimen. They face not only the risks of oral
disease that generally come with aging, but also compounding
problems specifically associated with estrogen therapy, among them
bone loss in the jaw and increased likelihood of tooth decay. In
addition, estrogen therapy is associated with bacterial changes in
the mouth and with lower salive production. Both of these effects
increase the risk of periodontal disease, which recent studies have
shown to be a factor in the development of coronary heart disease
and cerebrovascular disease.
Personal Finances
TG/TS older adults often experience the cumulative effects of
discrimination on personal finances. Unpublished data from A. Evan
Eyler and T.M. Witten indicate that incomes well below the U.S.
national average are common among FTMs. Because many FTMs begin
their transition only after years of lesbian identification, this is
most likely a result of discrimination they experienced as women and
lesbians. Conversely, MTFs who tend to be older at the time of
transition, may have enjoyed higher income during a long period of
male privilege before assuming their female gender.
Workplace discrimination also harms the financial stability of
the TG/TS older adults. Attempts at gender transition on the job are
at times met with dismissal; only one state and a handful of
municipalities provider protection from employment discrimination
based on gender presentation. Because financial resources in old age
depend very much on what people have earned throughout their lives,
TG/TS individuals who have experiences such discrimination may face
difficulties in covering their expenses in retirement.
Physical Transition
The physical phenomenon of aging may facilitate social gender
transition for TG/TS older adults. WOmen and men share more physical
similarity during elder years than at any other time after
childhood. For example, loss of facial skin tone produces a softer
appearance for many genetic males - a change that helps MTF elders
appear more female. Similarly, genetic females experience a shift
toward andrognization of the hair follicles as they age. For FTM
transsexuals, this encourage beard growth that produces a more male
appearance.
Furthermore, the loss of muscle mass and the increase in body fat
experiences by all elders often results in women and men appearing
more similar. These physiological alterations are clearly
advantagous for TG/TS individuals who begin the transition process
later in life, as they may obviate the need for weight reduction for
genetic males, body building for genetic females and minor cosmetic
procedures for both.
Family Relationships
Longstanding family relationships are frequently altered when an
older person reveals his or her gender identity. Most family roles
are gender-based; parenthood;, brother and sister roles,
grandparenthood, and other aspects of the family constellation must
shift to accomodate the new gender role. Young children frequently
have the least difficulty accepting cross-dressing, transgendered,
and gender-transitioning relatives, yet their parents' distress and
prejudicial attitudes may cause upheavals in even the youngest
generation's relationship with a TG/TS older relative.
Long-time spouses or partners of transitioning elders must cope
not only with their partner's changing identity, but also with the
threats it poses to their own sexual orientation, social standing
and sense of familial security. Some choose to continue their
existing relationship, but many do not. Those who do stay together
often redefine their relationships.
More versatile couples can maintain a sexual partnership, which
may or may not include a change in the non-transgendered partner's
sexual identity. Others choose to adopt new roles, defining their
connection, for example, as that of friends or siblings. Even when
the families are supportive, such adjustments take time and effort
and maybe wrenching for everyone.
Sexuality and Intimacy
The greatest obstacle to sexual expression among older adults,
particularly heterosexual women, is the lack of suitable partners. A
single MTF transsexual who undertakes gender transition later in
life is more likely to experience sexual deprivation than would have
been the case had the individual continued to be perceived as male.
And because the genitals of few FTMs look and function the way
genetic men's do, FTMs face the daunting prospect of having to come
out to potentially rejecting or hostile new sexual partners.
On the other hand, most transsexualsexperience a positive
development of personal sensuality when they finally are able to
live in congruence with their deepest perceptions of their own
gender. Professionals can assist in this regard by validating the
sexual potential of their older clients, offering counseling and
education when needed, and assisting family members to accept their
older relative's gender presentation and sexuality.
Professional Responsibilities
In the case of TG/TS and cross-dressing individuals, the typical
life transitions of the elder years are compounded by a number of
issues: disclosure and privacy; isolation from peers; specialized
healthcare needs; and the potential of ostracism and negative
judgements from healthcare professionals and other care providers.
Service providers can best assist these clients by providing them
with information regarding the importance of routine healthcare,
including preventive services; by arranging referrals to supportive
providers; and by educating others involved in the client's care
about gender diversity. this last endeaver must include medical,
nursing and social work colleagues, as well as unskilled and
semiskilled assistants.
In addition, professionals in the field of aging can help improve
the quality of life of older members of the gender community by
facilitating formation of support groups; educating leaders of
existing groups, such as those operated by religious organizations,
and gay, lesbian, and bisexual networks; and specifically including
transgendered people in visible roles withing retirement
communities, healthcare programs and other service networks.
T.M. Witten is director of the International Longitudinal
Transgender and Transsexual Aging Research (ILTTAR) Institute in San
Antonio, Texas
A. Evan Eyler is a family physician who has worked extensively
with transgendred patients. She practices in Ann Abor, Mich.
Cathy Weigel works in the Comprehensive Gender Services
Program of the University of Michigan Medical Center, Ann Arbor
This article is available in a longer version with citations.
Contact T.M. Witten, ILTTAR Institute, 12846 Maple Park Drive, San
Antonio, TX, 78249