by Jim Provenzano
Richard Greenberg is once again suffering from a case of perfect
timing.
Before his play, "Take
Me Out," about a gay baseball player's coming out, premiered in
London in 2000, former professional baseball player Billy Bean
came out, providing Greenberg with inspiration for another layer to
what he always wanted to do, write a play about baseball.
Around the time of "Take Me Out's" US premiere at Manhattan's
Public Theatre, the brouhaha surrounding 'Out' Magazine editor
Brendan Lemon's alleged pro baseball boyfriend made headlines even
without a name. Mike Piazza's subsequent coming out - as
heterosexual - furthered the media flurry.
In late February 2003, former Dodger Sandy Koufax, now in his
70s, issued a blistering statement, cutting himself off from the
Dodgers, as they are owned by Rupert Murdoch, publisher of the 'New
York Post.'
Two months ago, the paper's gossip column hinted about a
biography of a former baseball player being gay, and that the author
had allegedly made a deal to keep the player's sexuality out of the
book. Koufax's biography, written by Jane Leavy, had been recently
published by HarperCollins, which is also owned by Murdoch's
NewsCorp.
The 'New York Daily News' stated that Koufax was the player
mentioned in the blind item. The 'Post' then apologized, but the
'Daily News' didn't, providing more speculation about the subject,
and some free related publicity for Greenberg's play.
While former umpire Dave Pallone, former Didger and Padres player
Billy
Bean (both who've writtenautobiographies), and the late Glenn
Burke remain the only baseball names to have come out (but after
retiring), a variety of fiction books take on the theme, including
"The Dreyfuss Affair," "Changing Pitches," and "Out at the Old Ball
Game."
"Take Me Out's" script will be published by Faber & Faber in
March 2003, adding to the literary genre.
Yet, while rumors persist about other players, none have come out
while playing.
I talked with Greenberg on the phone only days before the
Broadway premiere of "Take Me Out."
Also premiering in February 2003 were a San Francisco production
of Greenberg's "The Dazzle," and a London restaging of Greenberg's
adaptation of Strindberg's "Dance of Death," which ran on Broadway
and stars Sir
Ian McKellen.
Q: "Take Me Out" has received quite a bit of attention in the gay
community, particularly for the extensive locker room scenes and
nudity. I had a similar experience, but on a lesser scale, in the
stage adaptation of PINS. But we decided not to have so much nudity.
One penis, and they don't hear the lines.
Richard Greenberg: But if there are six, they listen (laughs).
Q: There was a lot of speculation on some web sites about where
the best seats were for seeing the guys' bodies.
That's why I never read reviews or stuff online.
Q: But with the sensation of that, you hit on the aspect of why
homophobia is still so prevalent in sports, that awkward situation
perceived by homophobes, biggest problem, so why not show the
situation onstage?
It's usually the first question. 'What happens in the locker room
if you know a guy is gay'' On the one hand, I think I can tell that
the response to the nudity is exaggerated. There's enough during the
course of the play that it becomes commonplace. The most difficult
thing to get out of stage nudity is an erotic one, unless you really
work it somehow. But you can get other values. It becomes the sort
of vernacular of the play, that there are naked guys walking around.
In the context, it has varying meanings.
Q: The story continues with it.
(Director) Joe Mantello had this really good idea that worked a
couple of ways. When the first guy comes out and gets naked, and
claims that now that Darren Lemming (the gay team member, played by
Daniel Sunjata) is there, there's a kind of anxiety about it, but he
doesn't do anything to cover himself. That happens early in the
play. It's a very extended scene with the guy naked. By the time the
other scenes come along, it's established. It's like, 'Well, here
they are.'
Q: It's also about more than sexuality and coming out. You offer
a love poem to baseball in the monologues, comparing democracy and
baseball.
The whole point was to write a baseball play. I had to have an
angle. I knew that I couldn't write "Pride of the Yankees," or
"Field of Dreams." I couldn't get away with that, but I do have an
obsession with baseball. When Billy Bean came out in 2000, and he
said that the only way you could stay in the game and be gay was to
stay in, or if you were already a superstar. That gave me the germ
of the play.
Q: Did you make many changes for "Take Me Out" from the Public
Theatre version to the Broadway version?
I made a lot of changes. The third act has been somewhat
restructured and re-written. It's still a three-act play, but it has
one intermission. The first two acts probably seem closer to the
original than the third act, but there are some natural cuts
throughout. It's streamlined.
Q: So you did listen to some input, if not critics?
I listen to audiences and my director. Usually, I get to re-work
a play extensively, but this time it went from London to New York in
no time.
Q: Did you ever see that British rugby play, "The Changing Room?"
Yes! I did as a kid. That's why I'm so startled that people are
talking about the nudity, because there was a lot more in "The
Changing Room."
Q: Was that an influence on creating "Take Me Out?"
Not really, because I was only like fourteen when I saw it. I
only have a vague impression of it. It was very different, an
exercise in naturalism. I loved that, the vividness of the
production.
Q: The character of Darren Lemming seems idealistic compared to
the negative reports that Billy Bean gave. A team sport seems to
require conformity. It seems idealistic that Lemming expects that no
one should be concerned.
I don't know if it's idealistic. He does know it. That's what the
play challenges, his personal sense of acceptance that he carries
with him, that because of Darren Lemming, everything will be fine.
He starts out with a sort of beholden sense of self. He does go out
thinking that because of him everything is gonna be fine. It's all
worked, so why not this?
Q: But Brendan Lemon and his "mystery date" hadn't been an issue
then?
No, I had written the play in 2000, and his stuff happened about
a year later. It was really a stunning coincidence, but at the same
time, I wondered, 'Who is this guy?'
Q: There's a lot of speculation. The public, or some writers,
seem fascinated by it.
You kind of wonder who this guy is, and how the hell they kept it
so secret.
Q: And why is it such a big deal, when some other players seem to
know who's gay?
There is that aspect of someone's life being made public, and the
fan response, the press response.
Q: The feeding frenzy?
Yeah, I'd think these players want to concentrate. There are lots
of reasons. Some players who are utterly fine with it and some
aren't at all. I thought what was interesting was (NY Yankees
pitcher) Mike Mussina's response, when asked how he would feel
playing with a gay teammate, and he said, 'Well, I might already
have.' I thought that was amazing, for someone like Mussina to say
that, and he never says anything.
Q: So you don't see a player wanting to be categorized as a gay
athlete?
"Take Me Out" is close to identity politics, or actually the
classic theme of identity, but also the politics of it. The gay
baseball player who comes out would be like Jackie Robinson. When he
joined the Dodgers, there were scores of players in the Negro
leagues just waiting for that first brave man.
Q: For now, it seems easier for some actors. Sir Ian
McKellen enjoys a diversity in stage classics, and fantasy films
like "X-Men" and "Lord of the Rings" while being out and proud.
It's perfect though, because he's this very sweet-natured bad
boy. He's teasing and wicked in a way, but really a nice man. That
surprised me, because from my parochial American background, I
didn't expect English actors to have this verve. He's tremendously
approachable. It was amazing to watch him work, being inventive and
daring all the time.
Q: Being a gay playwright, do you feel a need to write about gay
themes?
It depends what piques my interest, enough to merit a play. I
don't calculate it. It's whatever the character is. Writing about a
baseball player was enormously transgressive for me. But I realized
that writing is all about that. All you ever do is write about what
you don't know, or who you aren't. That's the whole point, to go
outside the lines of yourself.
Jim Provenzano
Jim Provenzano is the author
of PINS,
a novel about gay high school wrestlers. In 2002, he adapted PINS to
the stage for New Conservatory Theatre Center. Check out his website
Jim Provenzano's Sports
Complex
More information for LGBT Baseball Fans & Baseball Players
is on the Temenos
Baseball Page